What makes a Key Lime Pie a Key Lime Pie? KEY LIMES, of course! We make ours with authentic Key Lime juice from Key West, Florida. This is one of our only imported ingredients, and we would never settle for less. Key Limes are small, zesty limes that really pack a punch — a very different experience from regular limes. This pie is exquisite – digestive biscuit crust with a key lime filling, topped off with freshly whipped cream and fresh lime zest. It’s unlike anything you’ve ever tasted before! If a Key Lime Pie isn’t made with authentic Key Lime juice, it’s not a real Key Lime Pie. This is the real deal.
Although we cannot write a message on this pie because of all the freshly-whipped cream on top, if you are celebrating a birthday, we can place a dark chocolate plaque on top that says “Happy Birthday”. If you mention it is for a birthday in the Special Instructions box, we will take care of that for you.